An overview of the phytoestrogen effect on vaginal health and dyspareunia in peri- and post-menopausal women.
- 2019-02-20
- Post reproductive health 25(1)
- Fatemeh R Dizavandi
- Masoumeh Ghazanfarpour
- Nasibeh Roozbeh
- Leila Kargarfard
- Talat Khadivzadeh
- Sareh Dashti
- PubMed: 30786797
- DOI: 10.1177/2053369118823365
Study Design
- Type
- Review
- Population
- peri- and post-menopausal women
- Methods
- Overview (systematic review) of two systematic reviews and 11 RCTs; databases searched from inception to August 2017
Objective
The aim of this overview was to evaluate the effectiveness of phytoestrogens on vaginal health and dyspareunia in peri- and post-menopausal women.Material and methods
Three databases including MEDLINE, Scopus and the Cochrane Central Register of Controlled Trials were from inception to August 2017.Result
Two systematic reviews and 11 RCTs were included in the overview. According to the findings, isoflavones increased the maturation value and attenuated the vaginal atrophy in the post-menopausal women. Topical isoflavones had beneficial effects on the vaginal atrophy. Similar efficacy was found in Pueraria mirifica and conjugated estrogen cream on dryness ( p = 0.277), soreness ( p = 0.124) and irritation ( p = 0.469), as well as discharge ( p = 0.225) and dyspareunia ( p = 0.089). However, the conjugated estrogen cream was more effective compared to Pueraria mirifica ( p > 0.005) regarding maturation index improvement. Comparison of fennel 5% vaginal cream and placebo gel showed significant difference in superficial cells ( p < 0.01), parabasal cells ( p < 0.01) and intermediate cells ( p < 0.01), whereas no difference was found between the oral fennel and placebo in terms of superficial, parabasal and intermediate cells as well as Maturation value. Administration of 80 mg red clover oil had a significant effect on superficial ( p < 0.005), intermediate ( p < 0.005) and parabasal and vaginal dryness ( p < 0.005) compared to the placebo. Flaxseed had also a trivial effect on maturation value. Genistein had a more prominent effect on the genital score. The severity of dyspareunia decreased by 27%.Conclusion
Phytoestrogens have various effects based on administration route and type on the vaginal atrophy.Research Insights
Genistein had a more prominent effect on the genital score
- Effect
- Beneficial
- Effect size
- Small
- Dose
- not specified
the conjugated estrogen cream was more effective compared to Pueraria mirifica (p > 0.005) regarding maturation index improvement
- Effect
- Neutral
- Effect size
- Small
- Dose
- not specified
dyspareunia (p = 0.089)
- Effect
- Neutral
- Effect size
- Small
- Dose
- not specified
discharge (p = 0.225)
- Effect
- Neutral
- Effect size
- Small
- Dose
- not specified
Similar efficacy was found in Pueraria mirifica and conjugated estrogen cream on dryness (p = 0.277)
- Effect
- Neutral
- Effect size
- Small
- Dose
- not specified
irritation (p = 0.469)
- Effect
- Neutral
- Effect size
- Small
- Dose
- not specified
soreness (p = 0.124)
- Effect
- Neutral
- Effect size
- Small
- Dose
- not specified
Flaxseed had also a trivial effect on maturation value
- Effect
- Neutral
- Effect size
- Small
- Dose
- not specified
no difference was found between the oral fennel and placebo in terms of superficial, parabasal and intermediate cells as well as Maturation value
- Effect
- Neutral
- Effect size
- Small
- Dose
- oral (dose not specified)
no difference was found between the oral fennel and placebo in terms of superficial, parabasal and intermediate cells as well as Maturation value
- Effect
- Neutral
- Effect size
- Small
- Dose
- oral (dose not specified)
no difference was found between the oral fennel and placebo in terms of superficial, parabasal and intermediate cells as well as Maturation value
- Effect
- Neutral
- Effect size
- Small
- Dose
- oral (dose not specified)
Flaxseed had also a trivial effect on maturation value
- Effect
- Neutral
- Effect size
- Small
- Dose
- not specified