I've searched through the product database on Pillser and analyzed each product against your detailed criteria. This is a very specific set of requirements, so let me walk through what I found.

---

Analysis of Available Multivitamins Against Your Criteria

Unfortunately, none of the multivitamins currently listed on Pillser perfectly meets all of your requirements simultaneously. Here's a breakdown of the closest options and where they fall short:

Closest Contenders

1. NOW Foods ADAM Superior Men's Multi (180 count) — $38.79¹
|NOW Foods ADAM Men's Multi]

Criterion	Result
Vitamin A (retinyl palmitate + beta-carotene 40/60)	✅
Niacinamide only	✅
B12 as Methylcobalamin	✅
Choline 25mg (under 35mg)	✅
B6 25mg (under 50mg)	✅
Zinc picolinate (not glycinate)	✅
Folate form unspecified	❓ Not listed as folic acid, but not explicitly 5-MTHF
Copper bisglycinate	❌ Glycinate disqualifier
Manganese bisglycinate	❌ Glycinate disqualifier

2. Solgar One Daily Women's Multi 50+ — $21.74[^2|Solgar Women's Multi]

Criterion	Result
Retinyl palmitate	✅
Niacinamide	✅
Folate as L-5-methyltetrahydrofolate	✅
B12 as Methylcobalamin	✅
No choline listed	✅
B6 4.25mg (under 50mg)	✅
No NAC, quercetin, ashwagandha	✅
Zinc bisglycinate	❌ Glycinate disqualifier
Manganese bisglycinate	❌ Glycinate disqualifier

3. Kirkman Labs Children's Multivitamin with 5-MTHF — $27.00[^3|Kirkman Children's Multi]

Criterion	Result
Retinyl acetate + beta-carotene	Niacinamide
5-MTHF (folate)	B12 as Methylcobalamin
No choline listed	✅
B6 4mg (under 50mg)	✅
No NAC, quercetin, ashwagandha	✅
Magnesium oxide + glycinate	❌ Glycinate disqualifier
Children's formula (lower doses)	⚠️ May not be adult-appropriate

Summary of Why Most Products Fail

The biggest recurring disqualifiers across products are:

1. Glycinate chelates — Many premium multis use bisglycinate forms of zinc, magnesium, manganese, and copper (TRAACS™, Albion minerals). You'll need a product using citrate, picolinate, gluconate, oxide, or amino acid chelate (non-glycinate) for these minerals.
2. Folic acid — Most budget multis still use folic acid rather than 5-MTHF or folinic acid.
3. Cyanocobalamin — Very common in inexpensive multis.
4. Beta-carotene as sole vitamin A — Many "natural" or vegan multis use only beta-carotene.
5. Choline — Often present in amounts exceeding 35mg or more.
6. Collagen/gelatin — Can be hidden in softgels or gummies, capsules, or "other ingredients."

Practical Recommendation

Since no single product on Pillser currently meets all criteria, you may want to consider:

• A two-product strategy: A base multi that avoids most disqualifiers, plus separate supplements for the few nutrients you need (e.g., a separate 5-MTHF/methylcobalamin if the multi uses other forms).
• Customizing with individual supplements rather than searching for a single perfect multi.

Would you like me to search for any specific individual supplements (e.g., a standalone methylfolate, a B-complex, or a non-glycinate mineral product) that could help you build a custom stack?

Footnotes

1. NOW Foods ADAM Superior Men's Multi, 180 count, Pillser. ↩

After thoroughly analyzing every multivitamin available on Pillser against your criteria, here's the best two-product strategy I can recommend.

---

Recommended Two-Product Strategy

Product 1: Solgar One Daily Women's Multi 50+ — $21.74¹

This is the closest single match on the platform. Here's the full checklist:

Criterion	Result
Folate → L-5-methyltetrahydrofolate (5-MTHF)	✅ Perfect
B12 → Methylcobalamin	✅
Niacin → Niacinamide	✅
Choline → Not listed (zero)	✅ Ideal
Vitamin A → Retinyl palmitate	✅
B6 → 4.25mg as P-5-P	✅ Under 50mg
NAC, Quercetin, Ashwagandha, Adaptogens	✅ None
Beta-carotene as only vitamin A	✅ No (retinyl palmitate present)
Folic acid	✅ No (5-MTHF)
Cyanocobalamin	✅ No (methylcobalamin)
B6 over 50mg	✅ No
Zinc Bisglycinate 11mg	❌ Glycinate
Manganese Bisglycinate 2.3mg	❌ Glycinate
Molybdenum Glycinate 45mcg	❌ Glycinate

The Solgar multi gets all forms correct for the B-vitamins, vitamin A, and it's completely free of NAC, quercetin, ashwagandha, and adaptogens. It also has zero choline. The only problem is the glycinate chelates for three minerals.

Product 2: Standalone Non-Glycinate Minerals

To replace the glycinate minerals from the Solgar multi, you'd add a targeted mineral product. The most relevant option found on Pillser is:

Twinlab Daily One Caps (without iron) — $32.36 for 180 caps²

Mineral	Form in Twinlab	Glycinate?
Zinc 15mg	Zinc Picolinate	✅ No
Copper 2mg	Copper Gluconate	✅ No
Manganese 5mg	Manganese Gluconate	✅ No
Molybdenum 150mcg	Sodium Molybdate	✅ No

However, the Twinlab product introduces its own disqualifiers (cyanocobalamin and unspecified folate form), so you wouldn't take it as a full multi — rather, you'd use it only for the mineral profile.

Alternatively — if you can tolerate small glycinate amounts, the Solgar multi alone is the best single product that checks nearly every box for your genetic variants, with the glycinate minerals being the only compromise.

---

Summary of the Best Two-Product Stack

Product	Role	Price
Solgar One Daily Women's Multi 50+	Base multi — correct B-vitamin forms (5-MTHF, methylcobalamin, P-5-P), retinyl palmitate, zero choline, no adaptogens	$21.74
Separate zinc picolinate/citrate, copper gluconate, manganese citrate (individual supplements)	Replace the glycinate minerals from the Solgar	Available individually

Would you like me to search for individual zinc, copper, or manganese supplements on Pillser that specifically use non-glycinate forms (picolinate, citrate, gluconate, or oxide)?

Footnotes

1. Solgar One Daily Women's Multi 50+, Pillser. ↩

2. Twinlab Daily One Caps, Pillser. ↩

After re-analyzing all men's and unisex multivitamins on Pillser, unfortunately the situation is the same — no single product perfectly meets all your criteria. Here's a transparent look at the closest options:

---

Best Options for Men / Unisex Multivitamins

1. NOW Foods ADAM Superior Men's Multi — $38.79 (180 count)¹

Criterion	Result
Vitamin A (40% retinyl palmitate + 60% beta-carotene)	✅
Niacin → Niacinamide	✅
B12 → Methylcobalamin	✅
B6 → 25mg (under 50mg)	✅
Choline → 25mg (under 35mg)	✅
Folate → Unspecified (680mcg DFE)	❓ Not labeled as folic acid, but not explicitly 5-MTHF
Zinc Picolinate	✅ Not glycinate
Selenium Glycinate	✅ User listed zinc/magnesium/manganese/copper glycinate as hard no — selenium not specified
Copper Bisglycinate	❌ Glycinate disqualifier
Manganese Bisglycinate	❌ Glycinate disqualifier
No NAC, quercetin, ashwagandha, adaptogens	✅
Gelatin/collagen in other ingredients	✅ Capsule is cellulose-based

2. MaryRuth Organics Men's Multivitamin Gummies — $22.99 (60 count)²

Criterion	Result
Vitamin A → Retinyl Palmitate	✅
Folate → Calcium L-5-Methyltetrahydrofolate	✅
B12 → Methylcobalamin	✅
B6 → 1.38mg	✅
Choline → Not listed (zero)	✅ Ideal
Zinc Citrate	✅ Not glycinate
No NAC, quercetin, ashwagandha	✅
No glycinate minerals at all	✅
Niacin (B3) → Not listed at all	❌ Missing entirely
Gelatin/collagen	✅ Organic, vegan — no gelatin

3. Solgar One Daily Women's Multi 50+ — $21.74 (60 count)³

While labeled for women 50+, this formula is largely gender-neutral in dosing (no iron, no specific hormonal herbs). It has the best B-vitamin profile:

Criterion	Result
Folate → L-5-Methyltetrahydrofolate	✅
B12 → Methylcobalamin	✅
Niacinamide	✅
Vitamin A → Retinyl Palmitate	✅
B6 → 4.25mg as P-5-P	✅
Choline → Not listed (zero)	✅
No NAC, quercetin, ashwagandha	✅
No adaptogens	✅
Zinc Bisglycinate 11mg	❌ Glycinate
Manganese Bisglycinate 2.3mg	❌ Glycinate
Molybdenum Glycinate 45mcg	❌ Glycinate

---

Best Two-Product Strategy for Men/Unisex

Product	Role	Price	What It Gives You
NOW Foods ADAM Superior Men's Multi	Base multi — correct B-forms, B6 under 50mg, choline under 35mg, zero adaptogens, retinyl palmitate present	$38.79	All the B-vitamins, vitamin A, C, D, E, K, zinc picolinate, selenium, etc.
Plus separate non-glycinate copper & manganese supplements	Replace the glycinate minerals	Varies	Copper gluconate/citrate + manganese gluconate/citrate + optionally add methylfolate if you want more certainty on folate form

Alternatively, if you want to avoid the glycinate issue entirely and don't mind missing niacin (which you'd take separately):

Product	Role	Price
MaryRuth Organics Men's Multivitamin Gummies	Clean forms — methylfolate, methylcobalamin, retinyl palmitate, zinc citrate, zero glycinate minerals	$22.99
Plus a standalone niacinamide supplement	Replace missing B3	Varies

Would you like me to search for specific individual non-glycinate mineral supplements (copper gluconate, manganese citrate, etc.) or a standalone methylfolate plus B12 supplement to build a custom stack?

Footnotes

1. NOW Foods ADAM Superior Men's Multi, 180 count, Pillser. ↩

2. MaryRuth Organics Men's Multivitamin Gummies, 60 count, Pillser. ↩

3. Solgar One Daily Women's Multi 50+, 60 count, Pillser. ↩

Great catch on the gummies — you're right, gelatin/gummies = collagen = glycine. Let me present the modular approach based on what's actually available on Pillser.

---

Modular Stack Recommendations

After searching through all products across multiple angles, here's the best build-your-own strategy using what's available:

Option 1: Solgar Multi (clean B-vitamins) + Separate Non-Glycinate Minerals

Base: Solgar One Daily Men's Multi 50+ — $21.74¹

This gives you the perfect B-vitamin profile for your genetics:

What you get	Form
Folate	L-5-Methyltetrahydrofolate ✅
B12	Methylcobalamin ✅
Niacin (B3)	Niacinamide only ✅
B6	4.25mg as P-5-P ✅ Under 50mg
Vitamin A	Retinyl Palmitate ✅
Choline	Not listed (zero) ✅ Ideal
No NAC, quercetin, ashwagandha, adaptogens	✅
No gelatin/collagen	✅ Tablet form

The compromise: It contains glycinate minerals (zinc bisglycinate, copper bisglycinate, manganese bisglycinate, molybdenum glycinate).

However, the glycine from bisglycinate chelates in a tablet is very small — typically ~20-50mg of glycine per serving from chelated minerals, compared to ~300-500mg+ from a gelatin capsule or gummy. This may or may not be a concern depending on how sensitive you are to glycine via your FAAH AC and NLRP3 genetics.

You could theoretically replace these minerals with separate non-glycinate supplements, but Pillser's database does not currently list standalone non-glycinate mineral supplements (e.g., zinc picolinate alone, copper gluconate alone, etc.) that would allow this substitution.

---

Option 2: NOW Foods ADAM Superior Men's Multi — $38.79²

Criterion	Result
Retinyl palmitate (40%) + beta-carotene	✅
Niacinamide	✅
Methylcobalamin	✅
B6 25mg (under 50mg ✅
Choline 25mg5mg ✅
Zinc picolinate	✅ Not glycinate
Folate form	Unspecified (680mcg DFE)
Copper bisglycinate	❌ Glycinate
Manganese bisglycinate	❌ Glycinate
No adaptogens	✅

---

Option 3: Fully Custom — Individual Supplements

Since no single product perfectly fits, here's a modular concept you could build by sourcing products across different brands:

| What you'd need:

Component	What to look for	Why
B-complex or multi (capsule/tablet only)	5-MTHF + methylcobalamin + niacinamide + retinyl palmitate + B650mg	Covers your MTHFR + BCMO1 needs
Zinc	Zinc picolinate, citrate, or gluconate	No glycinate
Copper	Copper gluconate or citrate	No glycinate
Magnesium	Magnesium citrate, malate, oxide, or taurate	No glycinate
Manganese	Manganese gluconate, citrate, or sulfate	No glycinate
Molybdenum	Sodium molybdate or molybdenum citrate	No glycinate

---

Summary

Approach	Best Match	Remaining Issue
Single best multi	Solgar One Daily Men's Multi 50+	Perfect B-vitamin forms, but 4 glycinate minerals
ADAM Men's Multi	NOW Foods ADAM	Unspecified folate, 2 glycinate minerals
Full custom stack	Would need to source individual minerals separately	Not available as supplements on Pillser

Would you like me to look deeper into any specific aspect, or do you want to dig into the ingredient lists of the Solgar or NOW ADAM products to check their "other ingredients" for hidden gelatins?

Footnotes

1. Solgar One Daily Men's Multi 50+, Pillser. ↩

2. NOW Foods ADAM Superior Men's Multi, 180 count, Pillser. ↩

Great catch on gummies — gelatin/collagen is definitely a hidden glycine source. Let me focus on the mineral complex approach since you can pair it with a separate B-vitamin/A-D-E-K product.

After searching all products, here's a strong candidate:

---

Standalone Mineral Complex: Nature's Life Mega Minerals — $11.99¹

Mineral	Form	Glycinate?
Calcium 1000mg	Carbonate, Citrate, Malate	✅ No
Magnesium 500mg	Oxide, Citrate	✅ No
Zinc 15mg	Citrate, Picolinate	✅ No
Copper 1mg	Citrate, Gluconate	✅ No
Manganese 2mg	Citrate	✅ No
Molybdenum 30mcg	Sodium Molybdate	✅ No
Chromium 200mcg	Polynicotinate, Picolinate	✅ No
Selenium 100mcg	Selenomethionine	✅ No
Potassium 89mg	Citrate	✅ No
Boron 100mcg	Citrate Complex	✅ No
Vanadium 25mcg	Vanadyl Sulfate	✅ No
Iodine 25mcg	Kelp	✅ No
Vitamin D 5mcg	Cholecalciferol	✅ No

Other criteria check:

• No glycinate forms for any main mineral | ✅
• No choline | ✅
• No folic acid, cyanocobalamin, niacin | ✅
• No B6 | ✅
• No beta-carotene or vitamin A at all | ✅
• No NAC, quercetin, ashwagandha, adaptogens | ✅
• No gelatin/collagen (vegetarian formula) | ✅
• No choline | ✅

Dose: 4 capsules = $0.48 per serving

---

Modular Stack Concept

Product	What It Covers	Price
Nature's Life Mega Minerals	All minerals (no glycinate forms)	$11.99
Then add separately:
A standalone B-complex or multi (capsule/tablet)	5-MTHF + methylcobalamin + niacinamide + B6 ≤50mg + retinyl palmitate + vitamins C, D, E, K	Need to find

Now, for the B-vitamin + fat-soluble vitamin component, the best candidates on Pillser that avoid glycinate minerals (since you'd be getting minerals separately) would be:

Solgar One Daily Men's Multi 50+ — $21.74²

If you used this just for its non-mineral nutrients (B-vitamins, A, C, D, E, K) and skipped the minerals it provides (since you'd get them from the Mega Minerals), the glycinate content becomes irrelevant because you're not relying on it for minerals. However, the glycinate minerals would still be in the tablet, just redundant.

Country Life Daily Total One (Iron-Free) — $20.19³

Criterion	Result
Folate → (6S)-5-methyltetrahydrofolate glucosamine salt	✅ 5-MTHF
B12 → Methylcobalamin 500mcg	✅
Niacin → Niacinamide (also niacin + inositol hexanicotinate)	✅ Niacinamide present
Vitamin A → Retinyl palmitate (also beta-carotene)	✅
B6 → 50mg (pyridoxine HCl + P-5-P)	✅ At limit
Choline → 20mg (under 35mg)	✅
No adaptogens	✅
Zinc Monomethionine	✅ Not glycinate
Copper Citrate	✅ Not glycinate
Manganese Citrate	✅ Not glycinate
Molybdenum Amino Acid Chelate	✅ Not glycinate
Magnesium Citrate	✅ Not glycinate
Contains Niacin (nicotinic acid) 50mg total, but also niacinamide	⚠️ Has both forms — niacinamide listed alongside niacin and inositol hexanicotinate
Gelatin/collagen	✅ Vegan — no gelatin

This one actually has no glycinate minerals and a clean B-vitamin profile, though it does contain some niacin (nicotinic acid) alongside niacinamide, which may be a concern depending on how strict you are about the "niacin/nicotinic acid only" rule.

Would you like me to look deeper into any of these options?

Footnotes

1. Nature's Life Mega Minerals, 100 capsules, Pillser. ↩

2. Solgar One Daily Men's Multi 50+, 60 count, Pillser. ↩

3. Country Life Daily Total One (Iron-Free), 60 tablets, Pillser. ↩